5 Min ReadAugust 14, 2024

3 Misconceptions About Dealership Service Departments

Three Misconceptions About Dealership Service Departments.

Misconceptions about franchise car dealership Service departments persist despite industry efforts to change the conversation. You know how it goes: Dealership service centers are too expensive; the technician around the corner will do the same work; etc.

As a result, many vehicle owners skip car dealerships and turn to independent and chain shops. Franchise dealers retain only about 30% of customers after warranties and maintenance programs expire, according to CDK Research. That lost revenue adds up to tens of millions of dollars every year.

Yet, as vehicles become more advanced with more technology than ever before, and as EVs gain more market share, the expertise that the dealer’s Service department offers is key to keep vehicles running the way manufacturers intended.

Every interaction your team has with a customer or prospect is an opportunity to change the conversation about your Service department. Read on for talking points to help counter three of the biggest misconceptions.

Dealerships Service Centers Are More Expensive

We recognize the dealership may cost more for some services; however, here are some things to consider when speaking with consumers. Dealers have dozens of auto Technicians and specialized experts, in addition to the right parts and OEM components, to perform all types of work in a short amount of time. Quality work and an efficient experience are important to today’s drivers, and dealership Service centers shine on both points.

And while technicians can sometimes offer services at a lower cost, dealerships can provide comparable prices thanks to monthly auto service specials, oil change coupons, and more.

Dealers also have an advantage when it comes to repairs outside of a warranty period and recalls because they typically guarantee repairs with a warranty that’s good nationwide. If the part fails, it can be fixed under warranty and at any franchised dealership. Independent repair facilities most likely can’t offer this benefit.

Other advantages to reinforce with customers include the breadth and depth of services only a dealer can provide. Whether it’s a standard oil change, engine or transmission repairs, the dealer can handle it all while smaller independent shops have limits on what they can do. Loaner cars or rentals are another great service to reinforce. Even if it isn’t complimentary, dealers at least have an option to keep drivers on the road while their cars are being fixed.

Finally, we can’t ignore the growing number of EV drivers who’ll need services that independent shops just can’t handle. Dealers are the best source for EV-trained Technicians. And in our most recent Service Shopper 3.0 study, trained Technicians were some of the most desirable features dealerships provided. It’s a good strategy to emphasize the advanced technology in today’s cars and explain why a dealership’s Service Technicians are another reason to come to a dealership over the competition.

OEM Parts and Certified Technicians Don’t Matter

Genuine factory-trained Technicians and OEM parts do matter. Service shoppers ranked them second and third respectively as their top reasons for choosing a dealer over independents and chains in our most recent Service Shopper study. Here are some points to bring up with customers who question the value.

Dealer Technicians are manufacturer-trained and typically work only on the brands a dealership sells. The likelihood of quality service is much higher than with a Technician who works on a particular brand only once or twice a year. Plus, most dealers have ongoing training programs for their Techs, Service Managers, Advisers and support staff to keep up with the latest upgrades and repair techniques.

When it comes to parts, the best way to keep a car running at optimal performance is to repair with the same parts it had when it rolled off the assembly line. OEM parts offer greater assurance of quality because these are the same as the parts on new cars and offer the same level of performance.

And the majority of manufacturers offer warranties for OEM parts and labor if something fails. A 12-month/12,000-mile warranty on parts and labor for repairs and/or service isn’t uncommon at the dealer level. And only dealers receive Technical Service Bulletins so factory-trained Technicians know how to make the repairs according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Aftermarket parts may carry warranties, but the customer is on the hook for labor costs if the part needs to be replaced or fixed.

When I Sell My Car, It Won’t Matter Where I Went for Service

This is a big misunderstanding among vehicle owners and it can cost them when they go to trade up at a dealership or sell to a private party. A comprehensive service history makes the vehicle more reliable and therefore more likely to command a higher price from a buyer.

The best way to prove a vehicle has received the maintenance it needs to run reliably is to service at a dealership. This is because OEMs and dealers keep digital records of all service history that can be easily accessed. Independents most likely don’t offer this type of assistance.

A service record is especially important to franchised dealers because it’ll determine how much reconditioning they have to do to a trade-in to get it front-line ready. The better maintained a vehicle, the lower the reconditioning costs, and the more a dealer will pay for the trade.

Service revenue is a dealer’s best bet for reliable and steady income. Turn every customer interaction into an opportunity for your dealership staff to change the conversation and drive more business into your Service lanes.

Share This

Don Zogg
By Don Zogg
Product Marketer, FixedOps

Don is a Product Marketer at CDK where he drives the marketing strategy for Fixed Operations. A 25-year CDK veteran, he is passionate about developing and delivering product-specific information to support OEM partnerships for our automotive retail customers.

Recent Insights

Are Dealers Moving to Where the Car Sales Are?

Are Dealers Moving to Where the Car Sales Are?

As we approach the midpoint of the 2020s, the U.S. auto retail landscape looks markedly different from just five years...
3 Min ReadAug 21CDK Global
Consultants Help Dealers Identify Improvements  to Increase Efficiency and Profit

Consultants Help Dealers Identify Improvements to Increase Efficiency and Profit

There is no denying the significant investment car dealers make with the software that runs their stores. But most dealerships...
4 Min ReadAug 19CDK Global
Leasing’s New Life as Monthly Payments Get Squeezed.

Leasing's New Life as Monthly Payments Get Squeezed

Leasing isn’t new. But as the market tightens and sale prices and MSRPs begin to rise there is renewed interest...
3 Min ReadAug 14CDK Global
C D K Research Uncovers the Truth About E V Ownership in 2025.

CDK Research Uncovers the Truth About EV Ownership in 2025

Electric vehicles have been a hot topic in the industry for nearly a decade. Today, the end of EV incentives...
2 Min ReadAug 7CDK Global
Four Requirements for Modern Dealer Appraisal Software in 2025.

4 Requirements for Modern Dealer Appraisal Software in 2025

Appraisals are an essential step in dealership processes. Even in today’s market where many dealers are offering top dollar for...
4 Min ReadAug 5CDK Global
Car Buying Process Rebounds in July

Car-Buying Process Rebounds in July

June saw the biggest drop and lowest score in the history of our Ease of Purchase scorecard. Luckily, there was...
3 Min ReadAug 4David Thomas
Three Ways Dealers Use Automotive Inventory Management Software.

3 Ways Dealers Use Automotive Inventory Management Software

Not too long ago, CDK conducted an informal survey of dealerships to see what inventory concerns plague them most. Some...
4 Min ReadJul 30CDK Global
How COVID 19 Strategies Can Help Dealers Pivot in 2025.

How COVID-19 Strategies Can Help Dealers Pivot in 2025

If the word of the year in 2020 was unprecedented, the word of 2025 may very well be tariff. Tariffs...
3 Min ReadJul 28CDK Global
The Evolving Role of the E V Salesperson in 2025.

The Evolving Role of the EV Salesperson in 2025

According to CDK data, vehicle satisfaction declined as electric vehicle buyers shifted from innovators and early adopters to the early...
4 Min ReadJul 23CDK Global
How Generations Like to Buy Electric Vehicles. Online versus In Person.

How Generations Like To Buy EVs: Online vs. In Person

Today, the automotive retail landscape is evolving at an unprecedented pace, with vehicle technology, consumer preference and politics playing crucial...
3 Min ReadJul 17CDK Global